Issue 2 - 2024 200dpi

2 June 2014 Edition

Resize: A A A Print

Media reaction

Elections 2014 Special

• Gerry Adams speaks to the media at the count centre in Dublin

Seeing An Phoblacht’s logo on the Irish Independent’s blog feed did prove that the world is changing

THE HEADLINES said “Sinn Féin surge ahead”; “Sinn Féin reign”; “Shinners sweep the capital”; “The arrival of Sinn Féin as a genuine heavyweight”; “Huge swing to Sinn Féin”. We could go on with the superlatives used in news headlines over the first three days of vote counting in the EU and local elections but . . . we would be missing an important point.

These elections were actually a failure for Sinn Féin and it was the Sunday Independent who called it!

“Sinn Féin surges – but falls short” was one of the front-page subheads in the Sunday Independent. Also on Page One, Brendan O’Connor wrote that “Sinn Féin is a fantasy political party” while, inside, John Drennan declared that the electorate had decided to “tamp down the Sinn Féin revival”. Philip Ryan believed “Sinn Féin’s romp has failed to materialise”.


A five-star result in County Wexford for Sinn Féin with Oisin O’Connell (New Ross), Mick Roche (Wexford), Johnny Mythen (Enniscorthy), Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin (Gorey) and Anthony Kelly (Wexford) all elected

The Sunday Independent’s reasoning behind the Sinn Féin ‘failure’ is that the party did not reach the support level in that paper’s Millward Brown poll. No chance the poll might have been wrong?

But there’s more.

“Sinn Féin preys on rising tide of fear” was the title of the Jody Corcoran article on the editorial page.

pg26-2Accompanying Corcoran’s piece was an Eddie Hobbs article on “Sinn Féin’s competence to move from Opposition to Government”. His conclusion was “it may take a dose of Sinn Féin in power to cure us of that party permanently”.

Cormac Lucey in the Sunday Times also attacked Sinn Féin. His article is profiled on the Business Section’s front page with the headline “Sinnomics — Economic Lunacy of country’s fastest-growing political party”. Lucey claimed Sinn Féin’s economic policies are “a study in evasiveness and wrong-headedness”.

Did you know the Independent News and Media Group, which the Sunday Independent is part of, has “been left the heavy lifting on exposing Sinn Féin”? I did like the bit that read “the major parties are in danger of being swept aside by Sinn Féin’s seizure of the moral high ground”. (The view is great up here, by the way.)

The online presence of the main news media outlets was a fascinating circus at the weekend.


Sinn Féin’s Ray McHugh and Críona Ní Dhálaigh, both elected for the Crumlin-Kimmage ward in Dublin City Council, with with Dublin Central TD Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS Count Centre

Seeing An Phoblacht’s logo on the Irish Independent’s blog feed (they were retweeting an An Phoblacht update) did prove that the world is changing, even at the paper once owned by William Martin Murphy of Lockout and 1916 executions infamy.

RTÉ and Newstalk led the way over the weekend. They were an addictive mix as we followed the minute-by-minute rout, showing the Internet’s power as a breaking news medium. Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny’s tussle with Newstalk’s John Keogh, and Kenny’s accusations about Newstalk, require repeated listening.

On Sunday, Clare Labour TD Michael McNamara’s call for Eamon Gilmore’s resignation set another news agenda.

On Monday 26 May, The Irish Times editorial begrudgingly declared, “Little wonder Sinn Féin has been able so successfully to embed itself as the third party,” though it went on to point out the difficulties to come, a theme enthusiastically taken up by Stephen Collins.

The demise of Labour is the key focus for the Irish Examiner, mutating into “Labour pain as Sinn Féin reign” in the Irish Daily Star. The Mail, Mirror, Independent and Herald all took this angle, as did The Irish Times headlining with “Labour TDs voice alarm over losses”. Gilmore resigned at 4pm on Monday afternoon.

Final words go to the Sunday Independent front page. It had a strapline reading “The revolt of the coping classes” and the headline: “Coalition feels the fury of the people at the ballot box”.

If only they really believed a revolution was afoot.


Sinn Féin’s team in Derry greet 99-year-old Ita Crossan who made sure to cast her vote in the Creggan ward


An Phoblacht
44 Parnell Sq.
Dublin 1