Top Issue 1-2024

3 September 1998 Edition

Resize: A A A Print

New in print

Missing milestones



Milestones in Irish History
Edited by Liam De Paor
Published by Mercier Press
Price £7.99

This is a series of essays originally broadcast on RTE Radio in 1993 and should more appropriately be titled ``Milestones in the twenty six counties' history.'' Events such as the1798 revolution and the conflict in the north over the past thirty years are mentioned only in passing.

However, it would be wrong to imply that this book is completely without merit. `Brian Boru and the Battle of Clontarf' by Donnchadh O Corrain and `The Norman Invasion' by Michael Richter are incisive and well written pieces.

Unfortunately these essays are followed by `The Flight of the Earls' by Margaret McCurtain. The scurrying off in the dead of night by the ``great'' Hugh O'Neill and Rory O'Donnell is romanticised to the hilt.

McCurtain asserts that this act of desertion, while a ``great misfortune'' for the people of Ulster, heralded the ``beginning of one of the most splendid pages of Irish history, that of the Irish abroad.'' It is a curious mentality, indeed, which can deduce any splendour from cowardice.

Other articles cover the EEC, the Irish language and the building of the great tombs at Newgrange and elsewhere.

`Partition' by Ronan Fanning gives an insight into the thinking of the British establishment in the first quarter of this century, forever looking for a quick fix to ``the Irish problem''. He concludes that British policy in Ireland has always been dictated by an assessment of British national interest rather than the harmony of Anglo-Irish relations, adding, ``So it has always been. So it seems likely to remain.''

Although many of the contributions are detailed, the book is of coffee table quality - with the exception of the Richter and O Corrain missives.

by Sean O'Tuama


Where has all the equality gone?



Launch preview



Seeds of Hope
Garvaghy Road Women Writers Group
Price £5
Launch in Green Cross Art Shop, Falls Road, Belfast
Thursday 10 September at 12 noon

The 10 September book launch at the Green Cross Art Shop in Belfast's Falls Road of poetry written by women from the Garvaghy Road in Portadown is a story of triumph over adversity.

In June this year, the Dublin-based peace group, Seeds of Hope, withdrew its commitment to support the venture. Despite support for the project from the UDA centre and the EPIC centre on the Shankhill Road, the peace group unexpectedly backed out, claiming that the project was not sufficiently ``cross community''. Subsequently over £900 remains unpaid to the printer.

Speaking to An Phoblacht, Philomena Gallagher, who led the writers' group, said, ``we explained to Seeds of Hope the importance of people telling the truth of their experience, no matter how painful it is, as a way of the different communities getting to know each other.''

Gallagher added that despite numerous pledges of financial commitment the printer was contacted last week by the Dublin group saying it had ``no legal obligation to pay and [had] issued no authority to use the `Seeds of Hope' logo''.

The rejection of the book by Seeds of Hope points to another more worrying trend. The move to censor any reference to the institutionalised inequality and sectarianism that has been at the root of conflict in the Six Counties indicates a deeper failure to understand the different experience of Catholics and Protestants. Without an honest appraisal of the pain, fear and hurt expressed in the Garvaghy women's poetry, it is impossible to recognise the inequality that has existed throughout the Six Counties since its inception.

The Belfast launch is being supported by the Felons Club and Black Mountain writers' groups, and despite the £5 cost of the poetry book, An Phoblacht hopes that anyone interested will get along to the launch to support the women from the Garvaghy Road. Alternatively, copies are available from Garvaghy Road Women Writers Group, Portadown, Co Armagh, BT62.

by Ned Kelly


An Phoblacht
44 Parnell Sq.
Dublin 1
Ireland