AP front 1 - 2025 small

22 November 2026

Resize: A A A Print

Policing at 25: completing the transformation

Twenty-five years ago, the establishment of the PSNI marked a defining moment in the transformation of policing and our society. It was a major achievement of the peace process and the Good Friday Agreement, recognising that lasting peace required a new beginning to policing, built on equality, human rights, democratic accountability and community confidence.

For generations, nationalists and republicans experienced the RUC through discrimination, collusion and abuses of police powers. The Patten Commission provided the blueprint for fundamental change through 175 recommendations, aimed at creating a representative, impartial and accountable service rooted in the communities it serves. 

While progress was hard won and some recommendations diluted or delayed, Sinn Féin consistently worked to advance that transformation.

But this was never simply about changing the structures and culture of policing. It was also about ending the influence of British securocrats and ensuring policing and security were subject to democratic accountability. Sinn Féin consistently challenged the role of the British intelligence establishment, including MI5, which continues to operate here beyond the reach and oversight of local democratic institutions. 

Sinn Féin's decision in 2007 to support policing was another defining strategic decision, rooted in our commitment to the Good Friday Agreement. It was about shaping new arrangements, securing democratic accountability and ensuring policing could earn the confidence of every community. It was never an endorsement of the status quo or a declaration that transformation was complete.

Twenty-five years on, the PSNI is not the RUC, and the relationship between policing and many nationalist and republican communities has changed profoundly. That progress must be protected. But the founding principles of Patten must be fully realised in every community.

Firstly, representativeness must be dealt with as a strategic priority. Patten recognised that policing could not command confidence while significant sections of the community remained under-represented. Removing 50:50 recruitment before this objective was achieved was premature. The subsequent decline in Catholic representation and applications demonstrates that historic inequalities do not correct themselves. Sinn Féin believes 50:50 recruitment must be reinstated, alongside action on retention, promotion and progression. Women, ethnic minorities, people with disabilities and other under-represented communities must also be reflected throughout the service, including in leadership.

Secondly, community policing must be protected and properly resourced. People want police officers in their communities, responding to local concerns and preventing problems before they escalate. Community policing, prevention and meaningful engagement must be central to service delivery. Communities must be partners in identifying problems and shaping local priorities. This is central to moving from conflict to consent. Policing must be about building relationships, protecting rights and keeping people safe, not simply enforcement.

Thirdly, accountability and human rights must be upheld. Patten's human rights framework must remain central to policing. That requires strong leadership and action to confront sectarianism, racism, misogyny and discrimination. Impartiality, human rights and community confidence must be non-negotiable. Accountability must also extend across the wider policing and security architecture. No agency exercising powers affecting people in the North should operate beyond appropriate scrutiny.  It is our view that all intelligence-gathering activities operating within the North should ultimately come under the authority and control of the PSNI, ensuring that they are subject to the same standards of democratic accountability, transparency and human rights oversight as other policing functions, including scrutiny by the Northern Ireland Policing Board.  This would bring the arrangements in the North closer to the model in An Garda Síochána, where national security and intelligence functions are integrated within the police service rather than operating through a separate intelligence agency.

Fourthly, legacy investigations must be taken out of the PSNI. The PSNI is not responsible for RUC actions simply because it inherited institutional structures. However, unresolved questions of disclosure and accountability erode confidence in current policing. Legacy investigations must be transferred to a genuinely independent, adequately resourced and human-rights-compliant mechanism, with the powers and access to information necessary to establish the truth. This will also allow the PSNI to concentrate on contemporary policing and keeping communities safe.

Fifthly, democratic accountability and all-island cooperation must be strengthened. We must protect the accountability secured through the transfer of policing and justice from Westminster in 2010. Ensuring future Justice Ministers are appointed through D'Hondt is essential to power-sharing, preventing any single party exercising unilateral political control. This is a fundamental safeguard of the Good Friday Agreement. We must also strengthen all-island cooperation against all crime including organised crime, trafficking, child exploitation and cross-border criminality. Criminals do not respect borders, and our policing response must reflect that reality.

Twenty-five years ago, Patten set out a vision for a new beginning to policing. Sinn Féin helped secure and deliver that transformation. We should be proud of the progress, but never complacent about the work remaining.  The British Government must honour the commitments underpinning Patten, address outstanding accountability issues across the policing and security architecture, and ensure the Executive has the resources to deliver effective community policing. The democratic safeguards secured through the Good Friday Agreement must be protected and strengthened.

Going forward we must complete the work begun by Patten. The next phase must be about consolidation, not reversal: protecting the gains, delivering the unfinished business and deepening confidence in a genuinely civic police service. Success will be measured by whether every community experiences policing as a service that protects their rights, responds to their needs and keeps them safe, within a framework of genuine democratic accountability.

Follow us on Facebook

An Phoblacht on Twitter

An Phoblacht Podcast

An Phoblacht podcast advert2

Uncomfortable Conversations 

uncomfortable Conversations book2

An initiative for dialogue 

for reconciliation 

— — — — — — —

Contributions from key figures in the churches, academia and wider civic society as well as senior republican figures

GUE-NGL Latest Edition ad

An Phoblacht
44 Parnell Sq.
Dublin 1
Ireland